Juvenile Justice System in Pakistan: A Critical Appraisal

Authors

  • Hafiz Ghulam Abbas Assistant Professor, Department of Law, Bahria University, Islamabad.
  • Anser Mahmood Chughtai Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Government & Public Policy National Defence University, Islamabad.
  • Khalid Hussain Consultant Ombudsman Punjab.

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.53575/irjei.v3.01.8(22)76-92

Keywords:

Juvenile, juvenile delinquency, juvenile justice system, Pakistan.

Abstract

This research delineates the concept of Juvenile Delinquency and unfurls the rudimentary underpinnings, requisites and contours of the Juvenile Justice System in Pakistan. In the second half of 20th century, the concern for protection of best interest of juveniles has attracted attention under international conventions and national legislation, whose overarching and overriding aim is to deal and manage this crucial issue of juvenile delinquency while keeping in view the ‘best interests of the child’ and ‘safeguard of their fundamental rights’. However, unfortunately some basic shortcomings persist in the overall Criminal Justice System of Pakistan to which Juvenile Justice System is a part, inter alia, overcrowding and inhuman conditions of detention centers, incapacitated staff of the prisons, callousness, abuse and exploitation at the hands of police, pathetic prosecution system and an overwhelmed judicial system whose eventualities culminate in problems for pre-trial offenders awaiting their trials, a fragile probation and parole system and lack of other diversionary measures to detention that can help reduce a great chunk of prisoners from already brimmed prisons. Juvenile Justice System particularly focuses upon not bringing the juvenile offenders encounter formal Criminal Justice System rather puts emphasis on alternate measures for the rehabilitation, re-socialization, and re-integration of the juveniles into the society. This research elaborately seeks to highlight the issues surrounding Juvenile Justice System in Pakistan and puts forward certain recommendations for the improvement of the said System with the aim of assisting policy and law makers to establish practicable strategies, translating Juvenile Justice System ‘on paper’ to ‘in practice’. For conduct of research doctrinal method has been employed with analytical and critical approach.

References

Mousumi Dey, “Juvenile Justice in India,” International Journal of Interdisciplinary and Multidisciplinary Studies 1, no.6 (2014): 64-70. Available online at http://www.ijims.com.

UN Congress, “Juvenile Justice: Before and after the Onset of Juvenile Delinquency” (working paper, Secretariat for the Sixth United Nations Congress, 180), 62-63, https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/juvenile-justice-and-after-onset-delinquency.

Defence for Children International. Belgium DCI, 2007. https://defenceforchildren.org/dci-belgium/.

Stephanie Hoffman and Corinne Baerg, “Juvenile Justice in Ghana: A case Study to Assess the Status of Juvenile Justice in Ghana” (paper, the Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative, 2011), 1-29, http://www.humanrightsinitiative.org/old/publications/ghana/JuvenileJusticeinGhana.pdf.

Barbara Henkes, “The Role of Education in Juvenile Justice in Eastern Europe and the Former Soviet Union” (paper series, Open Society Institute, 2000), 1-7, https://childhub.org/sites/default/files/library/attachments/347_410_EN_original_1.pdf.

Nikhail Roy, Mabel Wong, “International Standards for the Administration of Juvenile Justice and Examples of Good Practice,” International Journal of Law (2002): 1-25.

Articles 37, 39, 40 of CRC specifically touch the subject of the children who are in conflict with the law and require the special treatment for such.

The Beijing Rules 1985, The Riyadh Guidelines 1990, and UN Rules on the Protection of Juveniles Deprived of their Liberty 1990, The Tokyo Rules 1990.

Waiting for the Sunrise: Juvenile Justice in Pakistan. Islamabad (Washington: SPARC, 2003).

Article, 37, 39 and 40 of CRC particularly deal with the rights and protection of children coming into contact or conflict with the law.

Arshad Mahmood, “Child Rights in Pakistan: An Unfinished agenda,” The Express Tribune, November 19, 2014 https://tribune.com.pk/story/793859/child-rights-in-pakistan-an-unfinished-agenda/.

This amendment was passed by the parliament on 19 April 2010.

Qindeel Shujaat, the State of Children in Pakistan (SOCP) (Islamabad, 2015). https://mohtasib.gov.pk/SiteImage/Downloads/WMS%20Committee%20report/SOCP.pdf.

Ibid

The Juvenile Justice Ordinance 2000, Section 2.

The Sindh Children Act 1955, Section 5.

The Sindh Child Protection Authority Act 2011, Section 2(g).

Table developed for the purpose of this paper.

Substituted by Act X of 2016.

Khurshid Iqbal, “Judging Juvenility: Determination of age of Juvenile Offenders under Pakistan’s Juvenile Justice System,” Pakistan Journal of Criminology 1, no. 3 (2009): 105-118, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2305488.

The point of law, which becomes the basis of a judicial decision.

Mustafa Tariq vs. Pervaiz Ahmad, 2003 MLD Lahore-High-Court-Lahore 431 (2002)

Asghar Ali vs. the State: 2002 MLD 1566 KHC Sindh; 2003 PCr.LJ 1212

Juveniles on Pakistan’s Death Row (Pakistan, Justice Project Pakistan and Reprieve, 2015), 1-14 https://tbinternet.ohchr.org/Treaties/CRC/Shared%20Documents/PAK/INT_CRC_NGO_PAK_21444_E.pdf (Accessed on 10 Oct 2017).

Rehmatullah vs. the State, 2015 PCrLJ-Quetta-High-Court-Balochistan 1163 (2015)

The Table developed by the authors for the purpose of this paper.

Pakistan Criminal Law Journal

Supreme Court Monthly Review

Pakistan Legal Decisions

Monthly Law Digest

Yearly Law Reporter

Muhammad Riaz vs. the State: 2001 YLR 3096(b) LHC; Zafar Hussain vs. Ayyaz Ahmed: 2012 YLR 2865(b) LHC; 2006 PCr.LJ 430; Umar Hayat vs. Jahangir: 2002 SCMR 629 SC; Subedar Sabir Ali vs. the State: 2005 YLR 821 LHC; PLD 2009 Lah. 535.

Review of 2003 and 2009 “Concluding Observations” of the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child for Pakistan. See for detail on https://www.refworld.org/type,CONCOBSERVATIONS,,PAK,,,0.html.

Ibid

Pakistan: Submission to the United Nations Human Rights Committee, 120th Session, 3-28 JULY 2017, ASA 33/6380/2017 (London: Amnesty International Ltd, 2017), 1-22, https://www.amnesty.org/en/documents/asa33/6380/2017/en/

Wanger Tracery and Rizvi, Waiting for the Sunrise: Juvenile Justice in Pakistan (Washington: SPARC, 2003).

Juvenile Justice in South Asia, Improving Protection for Children in Conflict with Law (UNICEF, 2006), https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/51e7b5e24.pdf.

Imran Ahmed Sajid, “Juvenile Justice Policy: Gaps Identification and Role of Key Stakeholders in Pakistan,” Pakistan Journal of Criminology 1, no.3 (2009): 119-138.

O Connorand and M Cameron, Juvenile Justice in Australia-The Cambridge Handbook of Australian Criminology (London: Cambridge University Press, 2002).

Samra Fayyazudin, the State of Pakistan's Children (Washington: SPARC, 1st ed., 1998).

Basharat Hussain, “Social Reintegration of Offenders: The Role of the Probation Service in North West Frontier Province, Pakistan,” The Pakistan Journal of Criminology (2009): 26-39.

The State of Children in Pakistan (SOCP) (Islamabad: UNICEF, 2015).

Anees Jillani, Cries Unheard: Juvenile Justice in Pakistan (Islamabad: SPARC, 1999).

Juvenile Justice System Ordinance, 2018.

Juvenile Justice in South Asia, Improving Protection for Children in Conflict with Law (UNICEF, 2006), https://www.refworld.org/pdfid/51e7b5e24.pdf.

Table developed by the authors for the purpose of this study based on data published by SPARC in its series of reports titled “State of Pakistani Children”.

State of Pakistani Children (Washington: SPARC, 2013).

Guidence for Legislative Reforms on Juvenile Justice System. (New York: UNICEF, 2011).

Imran Ahmed Sajid, “Juvenile Justice Policy: Gaps Identification and Role of Key Stakeholders in Pakistan,” 119-138.

Ibid.

Ibid.

UNICEF, Juvenile Justice in South Asia, Improving Protection for Children in Conflict with Law 2006.

Ibid.

Jillani, Cries Unheard: Juvenile Justice in Pakistan. Islamabad.

Section 12 (b), JJSO 2000.

Section 16 (2), Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018.

Proviso Clause of Section 16 (Juvenile Justice System Act, 2018).

Jillani, Anees. Cries Unheard: Juvenile Justice in Pakistan. Islamabad: SPARC, 1999.

Criminal Prosecution Service Acts were passed subsequently after the promulgation of Police Order, 2002.

International Crisis Group working to prevent conflict world. Reforming Pakistan’s Criminal Justice System (Islamabad/Brussels: International Crisis Group, 2010).

Imran Ahmed Sajid, “Juvenile Justice Policy: Gaps Identification and Role of Key Stakeholders in Pakistan,” 119-138.

Downloads

Published

2022-03-31

How to Cite

Abbas, H. G., Chughtai, A. M. ., & Hussain , K. (2022). Juvenile Justice System in Pakistan: A Critical Appraisal. International Research Journal of Education and Innovation, 3(1), 76–92. https://doi.org/10.53575/irjei.v3.01.8(22)76-92